FINNEY, M., — Resurrection, Hell and the Afterlife. Body and Soul in Antiquity, Judaism and Early Christianity.
Routledge, New York / London, 2018. 1st paperback ed. VIII,203p. Paperback. Nice copy. Like new. ‘Mark Finney’s book provocatively argues against traditional analyses of afterlife in the ancient Graeco-Roman and Jewish worlds. The conventional understanding is that the Graeco-Roman world viewed post-mortem existence as non-bodily while for Judaism it was bodily. Finney believes that current views ‘are in need of re-evaluation for, in some senses, the reverse is true: the Greeks placed emphasis on the afterlife, for the resurrected hero, of an immortal physical body, while texts from the Hebrew Bible and Second temple Judaism focus their attention on the afterlife of the soul alone’ (2, 70, 179). (…) On the basis of this re-evaluation, Finney then argues that Paul is ‘consistent within Second Temple Judaism’ and therefore ‘concerned essentially with the soul and not the body’ (4). Thus, Paul. Construes Jesus’ death as followed by his soul being raised from the dead and then up to heaven’ (114, 180). Luke’s Gospel, however, changes Paul’s notion of a resurrected soul to be more in line with the Greek notion of bodily resurrection (4,139, 182). Luke’s view ultimately becomes a ‘point of theological orthodoxy’ in early Christianity (4, 154, 183). In the last chapter Finney changes course slightly by examining the development of eternal punishments and hell, which are in some sense ‘ideological constructs’ (5-6,173, 184). (…) Finney’s book is beneficial in its questioning of the current paradigm and raises important questions of clarity and nuance that will be appreciated by those interested in this subject. (…) Even those unconvinced by Finney’s alternative reading may find that disagreements of this sort help identify potential blind spots or assumptions and encourage greater clarity in describing ancient views of afterlife.’ (BENJAMIN SHAW in Religious Studies, 2029, pp.145-149).