Antiqbook

ESHLEMAN, K., — The Social World of Intellectuals in the Roman Empire.

Cambridge University Press, 2012. 304p. Hardback. Series: Greek Culture in the Roman World. ‘The second and third centuries C.E. were the period when Christianity spread and developed the organizational structure that would allow it to become the dominant force in the late-antique Mediterranean. They also witnessed the surprising rise of the Second Sophistic. Both phenomena have found lots of scholarly attention, but the way moderne scholarship has studied them can be compared to the way sophists and Christians lived in the same world without really looking at each other (…). Kendra Eshleman’s book thus is a very welcome addition to the growing body of scholarship on this period. It attempts to draw meaningful comparisons between sophists and early Christian writers, and it proposes a clear and convincing argument. E. is interested in the ways in which both sophists and Christians saw themselves as communities, deciding who belonged and who did not belong to their respective group. (….( individuals had to demonstrate their status through their words and deeds (…). The first chapter of the study (p.21-66) describes the mechanisms of regulating membership in these groups. E. is right to emphasise that in ancient societies, constructing one’s social identity was an ongoing activity: boundaries between educated people and laymen between Christians and ‘heretics’ were not fixed and unalterable (…). E.’s thesis is that there are enough structural similarities between sophistic and Christian group formation to make a comparative study meaningful. (…) The next six chapters are structured in pairs, with the first part (the even numbered chapters) looking at the sophistic side of these social processes and the second (odd) part looking at the Christian material. (…) The style of the book is clear and vivid; E. finds an excellent balance between letting her sources speak for themselves and analysing their deeper meaning. (…) The structure of the book with paired chapters works very well; I found it a pleasure to read. Nevertheless, there are also some problematic aspects in this study. (…) The parallel between Christianity and sophistic works well in some areas; in other parts, it becomes strained. (…) My final and most important complaint concerns E.’s use of the term ‘social world’. She never defines the word ‘social’ explicitly, but her study stays firmly within the limits of the discursive sphere of how sophistic and Christian communities saw themselves. Hardly any attention is paid to the larger political or social realities of the second-century Roman Empire. (…) But (…) E. is to be congratulated for encouraging scholars to see sophists and Christians as living together in the same world, following the same patterns of behaviour and self fashioning. Her study is groundbreaking in this area.’ (THOMAS A. SCHMITZ in Gnomon, 2015, pp.688-691).

Machine translation by Google. The original description of the seller is leading. Log in or create an account to translate descriptions. Accedi
Numero libro: 64582 €110.00 ($120.70 | £92.26 | ¥19,138)
Azioni
Richiedi informazioni Torna ai risultati
Prezzo
EUR 110.00
Autore
ESHLEMAN, K.,
Anno
2012
Legatura
Rilegato
Parole chiave