BRENNAN, T., — The Stoic Life. Emotions, Duties, and Fate.
Oxford University Press, 2005. XI,340p. Hardback with pictorial dust wrappers. Spine gilt titled. 'The Stoic Life is forcefully and skilfully argued, clearly organised and beautifully written. Part I, 'Introduction', begins by asking 'Why be a Stoic?' This is a provocative and stimulating way in, because B. presents a range of variously unsatisfactory construals of Stoic 'apatheia', concluding that 'if being Stoic meant being stoic, then there would be little reason to study their philosophy' (p.9). To see that this is only a counterfactual dismissal, we are invited to address the ancient material in 'The Ancient Stoics: People and sources'. (...) The ambition to communicate with (...) a broad readership is thoroughly admirable; but B.'s success in satisfying its diverse needs is mixed. (...) Chapters 5 and 6, 'Impressions and Assents' and 'Belief and Knowledge', are a great highlight. From here on, completely grown-up discussion, as opposed to smooth, if properly argumentative, exposition, is confined to the notes. (...) These chapters deftly construct a subtle account of Stoic epistemology, at once accessible to the talented novice and brimming with attractions for the more advanced. Chapter 7, 'Impulses and Emotions', nicely illuminated how, on the Stoic view, speciously benign 'pathê' might all too easily entangle us in vicious disaster. Particularly impressive is the presentation of the Stoic taxonomy of impulses, culminating in the category of (dis)selection common to Sages and fools. (...) Part III, 'Ethics', opens with a chapter on 'Goods and Indifferents', in which B. takes us through a catalogue of serious objections to the notion that one might rationally pursue the avowedly indifferent, and a series of responses on the Stoa's behalf. This is exemplary argumentation, a fine illustration of B.'s originality. Chapters 11, 12 and 13, on the 'befitting' are the philosophical core of the book. (...) I am confident that the book will prove of enormous value in all manner of lectures and seminars.' (ROBERT WARDY in The Classical Review (New Series), 2007, pp.355-357).