HARRISON, Th., — The Emptiness of Asia. Aeschylus' Persians and the history of the fifth century.
Duckworth, London, 2000. 191p. Original red hard bound with pictorial dust wrappers. Pencil annotations in Dutch on laste paste-down end paper. 'Thomas Harrison's 'The Emptiness of Asia' is 'a study of the historical value of Aeschylus' play, the 'Persians': its value both for the history of events and for Athens’ 'ideological conception and portrayal of their enemy, the Persians, and implicit in that portayal - of their image of themselves' (p.13). The book is composed of three sections. Part I contains three chapters, the first of which examines the problematic status of the 'Persian' as 'historical' tragedy. Harrison discusses the tensions between historical and ideological concerns shared by Aeschylus and his audience. (…) Chapter 2 challenges critics who believe the 'Persians' reveals a propaganda battle between Cimon and Marathon and Themistocles and Salamis and see Aeschylus' focus on Salamis as evidence of his political leanings. Chapter 3 argues that similar portrayals of Atossa in Herodotus' 'Histories and Aeschylus' 'Persians' point to the existence of a larger stock of anecdotes about the Persian court; from these anecdotes both authors derived underlying perceptions about Persia and Persian royal women. Part II, containing Chapers 4-8, explores Athenian ideology and self-representation. (…) Harrison (…) argues that Aeschylus' tragedy presents the war from the Persian 'point of view' only to highlight themes of Athenian devastation of the enemy in a strategy of patriotic stimulation. (…) Part III, containing Chapters 9-10, features Harrison's conclusions, which are vigorously argued and will excite great interest and debate. Harrison cautions us against using the 'Persians' as evidence of concrete alignment of political interests or expression of religious themes. (…) Hasrrions' lively book also contains a helpful introduction and notes and a fine bibliography.' (MARIA S. MARSILIO in The classical Outlook, 2001, p.31).