Antiqbook

OUDEMANS, C.W., and A.P.M.H. LARDINOIS, — Tragic Ambiguity. Anthropology, Philosophy and Sophocles' Antigone.

Brill, Leiden (...), 1987. VII,263p. Original gilt titled burgundy cloth with dust wrappers. Dust wrappers vaguely stained. Front cover cloth with some vague stains. 'This unusual book challenges all who believe themselves to have understood 'Antigone'. The authors set out the world-view ('cosmology', passim) implicit in the play and in the culture from which it emerged, and explore the differences between that world-view and our own, differences which have in their opinion placed wll-night insuperable obstacles in the way of interpretation of the drama. 'Antigone's cosmology is described by O./L. as permeated with 'interconnectedness', (...)an interconnected cosmology is one in which human actions, especially human transgressions, have repercussions throughout the cosmos. Beliefs about pollution thus form an important part of interconnectedness. (...) Also said to be central to interconneted cultures is the ineradicable presence of ambiguity and paradox, above all relating to power and transgression. (...) What is significant, according to O./L. is not the ethical status of the transgressors but the fact that they embody ambiguous power. O./L.'s mission is to rescue 'Antigone' from interpreters who have failed to recognise in it the presence of interconnectedness, thereby systematically misreading the moral dimension of the action and overlooking the work's tragic contradictions. Such misrepresentations may, they argue, be classified in terms of two frequelty-adopted strategies: 'seperation', and 'harmonisations'. (...) [A seperative] world-view relies on the thought-processes of abstractive reduction and on a total seperation of categories such as human and divine, or natural order and moral order. (...) A 'harmonising' approach (...) involves coping with the negative and contradictory aspects of experience not by seperating them in such a way as to defuse their impact. This type of approach is, the authors argue, unable to admit the full tragic contradictoriness of experience which in an interconnected cosmology remains undiminished. (...) The next and crucial stage in the argument is the analysis of 'Antigone' in relation to the three already-mentioned strategies: 'seperative', 'harmonising' and 'interconnected'. (...) It is not always clear to me what O./L. are driving at. (...) Nevertheless, the book's positive features undoubtedly outweigh the negative. O./L.' scholarship is impressive and up-to-date, and their sure-footedness extends beyond Sophocles into anthropology and continental philosophy. Above all, the authors have many stimulating things to say about Sophoclean interpretation, and have the great merit of presenting an approach to the nature of the tragic which is not just another rehash of Aristotle. I like very much the idea that the tragic dilemmas of this play can be seen as vain attempts to keep apart things which inevitable belong together. (...) Future interpreters of 'Antigone' will have to come to terms with this book.' (R.G.A. BUXTON in The Journal of Hellenic Studies, 1989, p.216-217).

Machine translation by Google. The original description of the seller is leading. Log in or create an account to translate descriptions. Accedi
Numero libro: 63886 €70.00 ($76.79 | £58.43 | ¥12,255)
Azioni
Richiedi informazioni Torna ai risultati
Prezzo
EUR 70.00
Autore
OUDEMANS, C.W., and A.P.M.H. LARDINOIS,
Anno
1987
Legatura
Rilegato
Parole chiave