Antiqbook

PINDARUS, — Carmina cum fragmentis. Edidit A. Turyn.

Apud Basilium Blackwell, Oxonii, 1952. Reprint ed. Academiae Polonae Litterarum et Scientiarum, 1948. XIII,402p. Original blue cloth with pictorial dust wrappers. Spine gilt titled. Cover, excluding wrappers, moist stained. Else fine. ‘What Turyn tried to do is to give us, after his researches into the manuscript ciliations, previously published in the works cited on page V of the prolegomena to the present edition , a text approaching as closely as possible that of the archetyped of all extant manuscripts and hence the text of Alexandria. (…) The question at issue is whether his selection among manuscript readings does or does not bring us closer to the archetype than any previous edition. (…) I think we may say it does. And we may say this not merely on the basis of our own judgment of style and sense applied to the separate passages singulatim, but on the basis of Turin’s previously established weighting of the value of the different manuscripts and families of manuscripts, as evidence. (…) Some of us therefore have, and will continue to have no doubt that Turin’s enormous labor on the text of the epinikia was more than worthwhile, in that it has brought us closer to Pindar’s own text, even though, as has been abundantly pointed out, the tradition of the manuscripts is in general so good that no great number of startling changes from earlier readings have resulted. (…) Even those who cannot share this opinion of the value of Turin’s text of the odes will welcome his re-editing of the fragments and will find indispensable the text and apparatus which he has produced. (…) In general the choice of supplements , where supplementation is possible, is excellent. (…) While we can (…) be grateful for Turyn’s work on the papyrus fragments it is in his presentation of those known to us from quotation in later authors that the student of Pindar will learn the most.’ (ELIZABETH WYCKOFF in Classical Philology, 1951, pp. 39-42).

Machine translation by Google. The original description of the seller is leading. Log in or create an account to translate descriptions. Accedi
Numero libro: 3132 €50.00 ($54.98 | £41.70 | ¥8,767)
Azioni
Richiedi informazioni Torna ai risultati
Prezzo
EUR 50.00
Autore
PINDARUS,
Anno
1952
Legatura
Rilegato
Parole chiave